Conspiracy Theories: Why Do People Believe Them?

Conspiracy Theories: Why Do People Believe Them?

“Conspiracy theories”—beliefs that the unknown, unidentifiable “THEY” are scheming to hide the “truth” about a nefarious plot against the unenlightened masses—are not a new thing. As a child in the ’70s and ’80s, I can remember hearing about moon-landing deniers, flat-earthers, and other such conspiracy nuts. The ’80s also brought us the “Satanic Panic”—the widely-believed claim that human-sacrificing, devil-worshipping cults were after… gasp… your children! Oh no!

Conspiracy theorists didn’t start with my generation, by any means. Tinfoil barely exists anymore—it’s all aluminum now, and has been since World War II—yet the phrase “tinfoil hat” is still used to refer to the supposed protective garb of conspiracists.

Were tinfoil hats ever really a thing? I digress…

Nutters who buy into crazy conspiracy theories have been around since long before the invention of tinfoil. They’ll probably continue long into the future.

Why do people believe in conspiracy theories?

Quite a few psychologists have studied conspiratorial beliefs and there are a lot of reasons people subscribe to such ideas. According to Psychology Today, the reasons usually fall into at least one of three categories:

  • The desire for understanding and certainty
  • The desire for control and security
  • The desire to maintain a positive self-image…
Conspiracy theories

This seems fairly accurate from my experience. Nobody likes to be uncertain. We want to know. “The desire for understanding and certainty” may be innate in all of us. Conspiracy-theorists, though, seem to need it more than most of us. They aren’t willing to accept ideas that don’t fit their understanding of the world. Many take comfort in beliefs that seem to explain things in a way that makes sense in their world-view.

We all have a “desire for control and security.” Everyone gets uncomfortable when we don’t have control. By convincing themselves that they are in on some secret knowledge, conspiracists gain a perceived degree of control. They “know” the “truth” and aren’t duped by conspirators like the rest of us “sheeple.”

Finally, conspiracy-theorists’ boost their self-image by “knowing” something the rest of us don’t. They belong to an elite group of “woke” individuals who “know” what’s been hidden from the rest of us.

Other reasons for conspiratorial beliefs

I think there might be a few other common reasons people believe conspiracy theories.

  • Religious conviction — In many cases, conspiracy theories are born out of religious dogma. Young-Earth creationism is a perfect example. The Satanic Panic of the 1980s that I mentioned above, too. Many who believe Earth is flat also use the Bible to support that belief.
  • Entertainment — Quite a few people simply find conspiracies entertaining. Whether they actually believe the claims or not is debatable, but often they will “try on” these beliefs like trying on a costume.
  • Power, fame, or money — This group of conspiracy-theory “believers” is one I find detestable. They may or may not truly buy their own bullshit, but their motivation is to convince others for their own personal gain. These are the charlatans who quite often are responsible for the spread of crazy (and often dangerous) conspiracy theories.
  • Racism/Anti-Semitism — There is a not-so-small segment of conspiracy-believers who attribute many alleged conspiracies to “the Jews” or other races. Holocaust-denial is the most obvious example, but it’s by no means the only one. Many if not most white-supremacists are dedicated conspiracists. I despise this group even more than the charlatans.
  • Paranoia — I hesitate to mention this one. We’re now delving into the realm of mental illness. I’m not a psychiatrist and I’m not going to spend time on this. It’s undeniable, though, that there are conspiracy-theory believers who could benefit from the help of mental-health professionals.

Are there any conspiracy theories that turned out to be true?

Actual conspiracies do happen, of course. Some of the ones we now know about were once thought to be “crazy conspiracy theories.”

  • CIA Auditorium, Langley, Virginia
    CIA Auditorium, Langley, Virginia
    CIA mind-control experiments — As outrageous as it now sounds, the CIA did dose people with LSD and other drugs, sometimes without their knowledge. The secret operation dubbed MK ULTRA was a Cold War-era experiment using not only chemical “treatments” but also hypnosis and even physical abuse. The CIA was looking for new ways to modify behavior and the experiments caused permanent mental disabilities in some of their subjects. You can read some of the CIA’s own documents on the subject here (opens in a new tab).
  • The Gulf of Tonkin incident — A reported attack on an American Naval ship, allegedly by North Vietnam, never really happened. It was a story fabricated to gain support for the American military’s involvement in the Vietnam War.
  • The government is spying on us — This one is fairly recent. People have talked about it for years, but it always seemed to me that most of us were joking… kind of. We now know that it does happen, particularly online. According to the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), “The US government… has engaged in massive, illegal dragnet surveillance of the domestic communications and communications records of millions of ordinary Americans since at least 2001.”
  • Tobacco companies lied about the dangers of smoking — For decades we’ve known that tobacco smoke significantly increases your risk of getting lung cancer. Tobacco companies knew this too, and we now know that they knew it.
  • Volkswagen cheated emissions testingThe company intentionally programmed some of their diesel engines to reduce the output of certain pollutants during emissions testing.

Those are just a few examples. There are others we know of and probably quite a few that we don’t. That fact that some so-called conspiracy theories turn out to be true adds to their appeal. It also should make us pause before dismissing such ideas out-of-hand.

Still, that doesn’t mean we should accept seemingly crazy theories without serious critical analysis. Many, if not most, are indeed as crazy as they sound.

The danger of conspiratorial thinking

What’s the harm in believing conspiracy theories? That depends a lot on how seriously you take them. There are a lot of people who believe in some. It might even be most people. In most cases, it doesn’t hurt anyone and is just a harmless idea.

That said, there is always a subset of believers in any conspiracy theory who take the idea far too seriously. They dedicate much of their lives to “exposing” the conspiracy. Often they believe that the perceived conspirators have malicious intent and must be stopped.

This can lead to extreme paranoia and, sometimes, to verbal or online harassment and, in the worst cases, even to violence.

Those are extreme scenarios, of course. It’s only a very small percentage of conspiracy theorists who go that far.

There are sometimes other risks, though. Take the anti-vax movement as an example. People who believe that vaccines cause harm are more likely to avoid vaccinating their own children. That poses a very real risk to society as a whole.

There are also more subtle harms. Conspiracy theories are like potato chips… you can’t “eat” just one. Once someone accepts that a conspiracy exists, it’s a lot easier to believe others. The bigger the alleged conspiracy, the more true that is. If you believe “THEY” are hiding one thing, it is almost natural to start to wonder, what else are “THEY” hiding?

As you plunge down the rabbit hole of conspiracy theories, gradually accepting more and more of them, it taints your ability to think critically about other things. It appears that some type of shift happens in the way a person thinks, becoming more suspicious of everyone—even those who want to help, like doctors.

Evaluating conspiracy theories

There is a risk to believing there’s a conspiracy when it isn’t true. At the same time, though, we know that there have been real conspiracies in the past. It stands to reason that there will be more in the future, and that there are almost certainly a few going on right now.

Belief in the existence of extra-terrestrial beings is central to quite a few conspiracy theories.

So, how do we evaluate the alleged conspiracies, to determine if there really is a good reason to be suspicious?

How did you begin to suspect a conspiracy?

This might be the most obvious clue. Unfortunately, people who have a tendency toward believing conspiracy theories almost never see it. It’s only obvious to those who don’t buy in.

Some warning signals that it might be a conspiracy theory and not an actual conspiracy include:

  • The source of information. Did you learn of the supposed conspiracy from a recognized authority on the subject involved? Or is it someone whose expertise is completely unrelated? Is the source known to be trustworthy? Or, does the source have a reputation for spreading rumors and half-truths? Is it someone known to be a rational thinker? Or, someone who tends to be suspicious all the time? Or someone who’s known for promoting wacky ideas?
  • What is the evidence that raised your suspicion? Have you looked at all available evidence? Is there evidence supporting a different conclusion?
  • Do you have any biases that might influence your opinion? Maybe your politics, your religion, your career, or any number of other factors make you more likely to want to believe one side of the story over another. Maybe you’ve had a bad experience with someone who is supposed to be involved. Are you self-aware enough to recognize your own bias? Can you set aside your bias in order to think critically about the situation?

How many people would need to be involved?

The more people involved, the less likely it’s true

Many conspiracy theories should be ruled out based solely on the number of people who’d have to keep quiet.

The conspiracy theory I most love to hate is flat earth. I plan to write a post on that one soon [update: so let it be written, so let it be done], and there are probably thousands of ways we know with no doubt that the idea is just ridiculous beyond belief.

Without even getting into science, though, we can rule out a conspiracy simply because more people would need to be “in on it” than there are people who’ve been duped by it. That’s a little bit of hyperbole, but not much.

A mass conspiracy of that level is just not sustainable. Just for starters, every astronomer (both amateur and professional), every airline pilot, every sailor, every astronaut, every science teacher, every U.S. president… and that’s just a tiny sample of the people who’d have to be aware that Earth is actually flat and, for some reason, want us to believe otherwise.

When you have a secret you really want to keep, how many people do you tell? It’s obvious even to children, the more people you tell, the sooner one of them will let the cat out of the bag.

What’s the reason for a conspiracy?

We can throw out so many conspiracy theories on this basis, too. I’ll use flat earth again, just because it’s so obviously stupid. If you ask a flat-earth believer why “THEY” would lie to us about Earth’s shape, the most common answer you’ll hear is, “To hide God.” You’re not supposed to ask any follow-up questions to that, though.

Like, how does lying about Earth’s shape “hide God”? Most people believe in a god. In the U.S., most people believe in the Christian God—the same God that most flat-earthers claim the conspiracy is hiding. Almost none of those Christians believe Earth is flat. So how does that “reason” make any sense at all?

It doesn’t.

If you’re ever suspecting a conspiracy about anything, the first question you should always ask is, why? And always ask follow-up questions. Does the supposed reason honestly make sense? If you really need to stretch to come up with a reason, there’s probably no conspiracy.

How complex does the conspiracy need to be?

This is similar to the number of people involved. The more complicated the conspiracy would have to be, the less likely it is to be true. Back to the flat Earth example, we already have near-perfect explanations of most phenomena related to Earth’s shape.

A conspiracy to hide the shape would have to explain sunrise/sunset; rotation of stars in both the southern and northern hemispheres; ships vanishing bottom-first over the horizon; gravity; seasons; and lots more.

That also means the alleged conspirators would have to somehow convince all of us that the “fake” explanations for all those things and more, are true. They don’t just need to convince the uneducated. They need everyone who isn’t “in on it” to accept their “fake” explanations.

It gets worse, still. Not only would the conspiracy need to explain all those things and more; it would need to explain them all together. I’ve heard explanations for most of those things I mentioned individually, but never once have I heard an explanation that is compatible with the other explanations. Not from flat-earthers, that is. Science explains it all perfectly.

Few conspiracy theories are as silly as flat Earth, but many of them are nearly as complex. When the conspiracy’s explanations are more complex or harder to understand than the commonly-accepted explanations, they’re probably wrong. Occam’s Razor is useful, here.

Can it be debunked?

This one probably sounds ridiculous on the surface. If it could be debunked, why would we be questioning it to begin with?

The problem is that conspiracy theorists very frequently will outright deny all evidence against their favorite “theories.” The ideas become unfalsifiable, meaning that there is no method to disprove them that would satisfy the believers.

If you learn of an alleged conspiracy and any evidence you present that might contradict the “theory” is rejected out-of-hand, without any critical analysis at all, you’re dealing with an intellectually dishonest person. The simplest question you might ask that person is, “What would convince you you’re wrong?” If they have no answer, you can safely disregard their opinion.

Conspiracies do exist. It would be just as ridiculous to deny that fact as it is to accept every claim of a conspiracy. You owe it to yourself and to society as a whole, though, to put on your skeptic hat when you’re presented with such an idea.

So, let me hear your feedback. Do you believe any conspiracy theories? Are there any you used to believe but don’t anymore? What convinced you, and what changed your mind?

Let me know in the comments!

Leave a Reply